In defense of a regulated system of compensated egg donation for research

In defense of a regulated system of compensated egg donation for research

Aramesh, Kiarash

6/20/14

English

20140620

Monetary compensation for human eggs used in research is a controversial issue and raises major concerns about women’s health and rights, including the potential of exploitation and undue inducement. Human eggs are needed for various types of studies and without payment, it would be impossible to procure sufficient eggs for vital research. Therefore, a solution seems necessary to prevent exploitation and resolve other ethical concerns while ensuring sufficient supplies of human eggs for research. A brief review of legislation in different countries shows the existing diversity and controversy over compensating human egg donation for research purposes. While in more economically developed countries procreative liberty and consumer orientation seem to be defensible, in some developing countries, where concerns about exploitation exist, adopting a more regulated approach to assisted reproduction is more prudent and wise. Egg sharing is a program that has been proposed to solve both the ethical problems of purchasing eggs and the shortage of human egg supply for research. In developing countries, however, regardless of whether the egg sharing or the monetary compensation model is adopted, some steps should be taken to guarantee the ethical nature of this practice. These steps include ensuring the existence of independent institutional review boards (IRBs), confirming the validity of all steps in the process of obtaining informed consent, and ensuring the existence and viability of independent supervising and auditing bodies.

14.2

14.1;19.5;1.3.9;2.1

clinical ethics--[pri];compensation--[pri];ovum donors--[pri];research ethics--[pri]

embryonic stem cells;gene therapy;public policy;reproductive technologies;research;women's health

Iran

Journal of the Medical Ethics and History of Medicine2014 June 20; 7(10: 6 p.

Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 3.0 Unported License

citation

25 refs

20080387 (online)